Where you base yourself splits along the same north-south line as the day passes. Rodney Bay and Gros Islet in the north are the easygoing, walkable option, with Reduit Beach, restaurants, and nightlife all within reach, while Soufriere down south is where the island's postcard scenery lives, with the Pitons rising straight out of the sea.
If you want the Pitons as your view rather than just your day trip, Sugar Beach, A Viceroy Resort sits on the beach directly between the two peaks, and Jade Mountain takes it further with open-walled suites and private infinity pools facing the same view. Both lean romantic and adults-focused, so they suit honeymooners more than families.
For an easier base near the Rodney Bay day pass hotels, staying in Gros Islet keeps you a short walk or drive from The Landings, Harbor Club, and Cap Maison, with more restaurant and bar options on your doorstep than you'll find further south.