Forio is the most practical base: a walkable historic centre, some of the island's best beaches, and Giardini Poseidon Terme within easy reach. Mezzatorre Hotel & Thermal Spa sits just outside town in a converted 16th-century watchtower, with its own thermal spa and private beach, if you want a proper splurge to match the island's spa culture.
For something quieter, Lacco Ameno pairs naturally with a Negombo day pass, since Hotel della Baia sits inside the park itself and includes entry with your stay. Sant'Angelo, the car-free fishing village on the south coast, suits a slower pace; Park Hotel Miramare sits on the cliffs above Maronti beach with a pool and complimentary access to the area's thermal gardens.
Ischia moves at a gentler pace than Capri, so wherever you base yourself, expect wellness and quiet over nightlife, with Ischia Porto the exception if you want restaurants and bars within walking distance.